Caribbean Pie Co.

The Caribbean Pie Company, is a multi-year award-winning company, voted People's Choice for "Best Pie" again this year (2022)! Known for selling the "Best Key Lime Pie in Sarasota" they have produced and sold their pies and other delicious mouth-watering treats for 35+ years in the Sarasota area. 

Most recently, the company was acquired by its new owner, Kevin Wood, an Ohio native, who is committed to continuing the tradition of delivering the same recipes that were developed many years ago. 

Though the retail location has changed a few times - the recipes have not - the pies continue to be made by hand in small batches. The Caribbean Pie Company's Key Lime pie has been the choice for many generations to celebrate special occasions and events.  

Locally owned and operated, the company proudly uses natural ingredients to make fresh pies daily. All pies can be ordered in a gluten-free graham or chocolate crust for an additional charge. 

You Can Find The Caribbean Pie Company at Local Farmers Markets!

  • Sarasota Farmers Market - Saturdays
  • Venice Farmers Market - Saturdays 
  • Englewood Farmers Market - Thursdays
  • Lakewood Ranch Farmers Market  - Sundays 

Stop out for a cool refreshing treat - Key Lime Pie on a stick!  

It's a local favorite - and if you haven't tried one - you are missing out!  

Caribbean Pie Co.


Follow us on Instagram